Christian Nationalism: What It Is, Why It's Theologically Wrong, and What Faithful Patriotism Looks Like

Christian nationalism is one of the most discussed and least precisely defined terms in contemporary American religious discourse. Its defenders claim they're simply asserting that America was founded on Christian principles and should return to them. Its critics argue it is an effort to establish Christian cultural and political supremacy that is fundamentally at odds with both democratic pluralism and the teachings of Jesus.

Both characterizations contain elements of truth. But the most important critique of Christian nationalism is not primarily political — it is theological. The fundamental problem with Christian nationalism is not that it's bad for America. It's that it's bad for Christianity.

This guide attempts to define what Christian nationalism actually is, identify its specific theological errors, and articulate what faithful Christian engagement with one's nation actually looks like.

Defining Christian Nationalism

Christian nationalism is not simply the belief that Christianity has influenced American history (this is historically accurate) or the belief that Christians should participate in political life (this is uncontroversial). It is a specific ideological framework with several characteristic features:

1. The conflation of national and Christian identity. Christian nationalism treats American identity and Christian identity as essentially coextensive — to be a true American is to be Christian, and to be a true Christian is to be American. This produces the identification of enemies of America with enemies of Christianity and vice versa.

2. The belief that America has a special covenant with God. Christian nationalism often employs the language of covenant to describe America's relationship with God — drawing on Puritan typology that read America as a "New Israel" and New England as a "City on a Hill." In this framework, America's military and political successes are divine blessing, and its setbacks are divine discipline.

3. The pursuit of Christian cultural and political dominance. Christian nationalism generally aims at a society governed by Christian principles and led by Christian leaders — in which Christian practices and values are privileged in law, culture, and public life. The more explicit versions of this (dominionism, Seven Mountain Mandate theology) aim at direct Christian control of major cultural institutions.

4. The equation of Christian values with a particular political agenda. Christian nationalists typically identify a specific political agenda as the Christian agenda — so that to vote against that agenda is to vote against Christianity, and to support it is to demonstrate Christian faithfulness.

The Specific Theological Problems

Problem 1: It confuses the kingdom of God with a human political order.

The kingdom of God, in Jesus's teaching, is not a nation-state or a political arrangement. "My kingdom is not of this world," Jesus told Pilate (John 18:36). When his disciples asked about the restoration of the kingdom to Israel (Acts 1:6), Jesus redirected them to the Spirit's mission that would spread the gospel to "the ends of the earth" — not the establishment of political Israel. The kingdom Jesus inaugurated is present wherever the Spirit of God is at work — in every nation, culture, and political system — and it will not be completed by any human political project.

Christian nationalism, by contrast, identifies the kingdom of God with a specific national political order, which requires the nation to be protected and advanced as the locus of God's purposes.

Problem 2: It produces the idolatry of the nation.

The prophets were extraordinarily clear about the idolatry of trusting in national power: "Do not put your trust in princes, in human beings, who cannot save" (Psalm 146:3). Isaiah mocked both military alliances and political strategies as alternatives to trust in God. The prophetic critique of Israel's nationalism — the tendency to equate God's purposes with Israel's national prosperity — is one of the recurring themes of the Hebrew prophets.

Christian nationalism is vulnerable to the same prophetic critique: it elevates the nation to the status of the vehicle of God's redemptive purposes, producing a kind of civil religion in which the nation is the object of quasi-religious devotion.

Problem 3: It makes the gospel dependent on cultural power.

Christian nationalism assumes that Christianity's flourishing depends on its political and cultural dominance. This is the exact opposite of the New Testament's model: the early church grew most rapidly under political marginalization and persecution. The church in China under Communist rule has grown dramatically. The church in Western Europe, where Christianity had cultural dominance for centuries, has largely collapsed.

The gospel does not need cultural power. In fact, the history suggests that cultural power is often harmful to the church — producing nominalism, the corruption of power, and the conflation of social conformity with genuine faith.

Problem 4: It excludes and alienates people the gospel is for.

"There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus" (Galatians 3:28). The gospel is addressed to every person of every nation, culture, and political identity. Christian nationalism, by making American identity a component of Christian identity, effectively communicates to non-American Christians and non-Christian Americans that the faith is not for them — or not for them equally.

The church's mission is to make disciples of all nations (Matthew 28:19-20) — not to make all nations American.

What Faithful Patriotism Looks Like

The alternative to Christian nationalism is not the denial that Christians should love their country or participate in political life. The alternative is faithful citizenship — love of country that is not ultimate, participation in political life that is not idolatrous, and engagement with cultural questions that doesn't confuse Christian faithfulness with national identity.

Faithful patriotism is penultimate, not ultimate. Christians can love their country, be grateful for its history, and work for its flourishing — without treating it as the vehicle of God's redemptive purposes or the center of their ultimate loyalty. "Our citizenship is in heaven" (Philippians 3:20) doesn't mean Christians are indifferent to earthly citizenship; it means the heavenly citizenship is primary and the earthly is penultimate — real and important, but not ultimate.

Faithful patriotism includes prophetic critique. Love of country includes the willingness to name the ways the country falls short of justice. The Hebrew prophets loved Israel and called it to account for its failures. The Black church tradition in America is perhaps the most significant example of faithful Christian patriotism — loving America while refusing to be silent about its failures to live up to its own stated ideals. Christian nationalism tends to silence this prophetic voice; faithful patriotism requires it.

Faithful patriotism is hospitality to the foreigner. The specific repeated command to love and protect the stranger, the foreigner, and the immigrant in the Old Testament (Leviticus 19:33-34; Deuteronomy 10:18-19) and Jesus's parable of the Good Samaritan, in which the despised foreigner is the model of love (Luke 10:25-37), makes Christian nationalism's frequent hostility toward immigrants theologically untenable.

Faithful citizenship is not partisan. Christians across the political spectrum can be genuine disciples, and the specific political alignment of the church with any political party is damaging to the church's witness and mission. When the church becomes identified with a political party, it becomes unable to speak prophetically to that party's failures, and it communicates to people who affiliate with the other party that the gospel is not for them.

A Prayer for the Nation

Lord, we love this country — with the specific love of people who live here, who have built things here, who have been shaped by its history and its landscape and its people. We are grateful for what is good.

And we know that You are the God of all nations — not ours especially, not ours uniquely. You are working Your purposes through every culture and every political system. You don't need America to be great in order to fulfill Your plans.

Give us the patriotism that includes prophetic love — the willingness to name what falls short, to work for what's just, and to care for the people our systems have excluded. And keep us from the idolatry of making the nation what only You can be.

Amen.

Testimonio includes reflections on faith and civic life, including meditations on what it means to be citizens of heaven in earthly nations. Download the app.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Christian nationalism the same as simply being conservative politically? No. Many politically conservative Christians are not Christian nationalists — they hold traditional Christian moral positions without the framework of national covenant theology, cultural dominance goals, or the conflation of American and Christian identity. Christian nationalism is a specific ideological framework that goes beyond ordinary political conservatism.

Is it wrong for Christians to want their values reflected in law and culture? No. Christians, like all citizens in a democracy, appropriately advocate for the policies and values they believe are good for society. The problem with Christian nationalism is not that it advocates for policies — it's the theological framework that identifies those policies as God's kingdom agenda, that treats political defeats as attacks on Christianity itself, and that uses Christian identity as a tool of cultural exclusion.

What do I say to a family member who seems to be embracing Christian nationalism? The most useful approach is usually questions rather than arguments: "What do you think Jesus meant when he said 'my kingdom is not of this world'?" "How do you think about the Christians in China or Nigeria or Brazil — are they part of the same faith we are?" "What do you think about the prophets who challenged Israel's nationalism?" These questions open space for theological reflection rather than triggering defensiveness.